News & insights

Blog

Stay up to date with our latest projects, structural tips and news on permits and regulations.

Structural advice Utrecht

Municipal review

calendar_today
person Structural engineer Siemelink

Professional advice and calculations from Sterkteberekeningen, your independent structural engineer in and around Utrecht.

In a municipality in South Holland, while helping a client who had to get municipal approval again to install a staircase, I found that the reinforcement that had previously been approved was insufficient. See the calculation below. Floor span l = 5.15 + 0.125 + 0.09 = 5.365 m Design load per m² pd = 1.2 × 0.22 × 25 + 1.3 × 1.75 = 8.9 kN/m² Span moment per m = Mv/m = (9/128)pl² = 18 kNm Fixed-end moment per m = Mi/m = pl²/8 = 32 kNm concrete cover = 30 mm; assuming ø10 reinforcement, the internal lever arm becomes 0.9 × (220 – 30 – 5) = 166 mm Required span reinforcement without opening trimming per m Av/m = 18/{0.435 kN/mm² × 0.166 m} = 249 mm²/m = 125 mm²/0.5 m Required minimum span reinforcement without opening trimming 0.15% × 220 = 330 mm²/m = 165 mm²/0.5 m Required support reinforcement without opening trimming Ai/m = 32/{0.435 kN/mm² × 0.166 m} = 443 mm² = 222 mm²/0.5 m Because the opening is larger than 400 × 400 mm, two strips of 0.5 m carry the load that cannot be transferred to the 0.7 × 1.2 m opening. These strips are therefore loaded 0.35/0.5 = 70% more1. The total required span reinforcement then becomes per 0.5 m Av/0.5m = 1.7 × 125 mm²/0.5 m = 213 mm²/0.5 m > 165 mm²/0.5 m, so 213 mm/0.5 m governs. Present is 2ø10 + ø7.5-150 = 157 + 147 = 304 mm²/0.5 m, so the bottom reinforcement is sufficient. The total required top reinforcement then becomes per 0.5 m Av/0.5m = 1.7 × 222 = 377 mm²/0.5m Present is 434 mm/m = 217 mm²/0.5m, i.e. only 65% of what is needed. For the top reinforcement, in practice a wider load spread could be assumed. Assuming, say, 2 m of load spread, then 70%/4 = 17.5% extra reinforcement is required. This is not present either, but given the higher safety factors it will not lead to failure. In addition, the loads on the second-floor slab will remain limited. Whereas the engineers who had submitted their calculation needed many pages of a document running to more than a hundred pages, I could make do with a single A4 sheet. The unclear presentation is probably also why the municipality in question did not recognise the incorrect calculation as wrong.

Need a structural calculation in Utrecht?

Planning a renovation, wall opening or extension and looking for an expert structural engineer in Utrecht? Sterkteberekeningen delivers fast, certified structural calculations in line with the Bouwbesluit (Dutch Building Decree). Get in touch today through our contact page for professional advice.